Agar agar has become a popular plant-based gelling agent in modern kitchens, especially among vegetarians and vegans. Extracted from red seaweed, it is widely used to set puddings, jellies, cheesecakes, custards, marshmallows, and even decorative cake toppings. But what happens when a recipe calls for agar agar and you don’t have it on hand?

Whether you are baking at home or developing commercial recipes for your brand, understanding how to substitute agar agar correctly is essential. Agar behaves differently from many other thickeners and gelling agents, so choosing the right alternative depends on the type of recipe you’re preparing.

In this detailed guide, you’ll learn:

• What agar agar does in baking
• Why you might need a substitute
• The best agar agar replacements
• Conversion ratios
• How substitutes affect texture and taste
• Vegan and non-vegan alternatives
• Professional tips for perfect results

Let’s begin.

What Is Agar Agar and Why Is It Used in Baking?

Agar agar is a natural polysaccharide derived from seaweed. It acts as:

• A gelling agent
• A thickener
• A stabilizer
• A vegetarian alternative to gelatin

Unlike gelatin, agar sets firmly at room temperature and does not require refrigeration to solidify. It also produces a firmer and more brittle gel compared to the elastic texture of gelatin.

In baking and dessert recipes, agar agar is commonly used in:

• Vegan cheesecakes
• Mirror glazes
• Fruit jellies
• Panna cotta
• Custards
• Mousses
• Marshmallows
• Toppings and fillings

However, because agar sets quickly and firmly, replacing it requires understanding the final texture you want.

Why You Might Need to Substitute Agar Agar

There are several reasons you may need an alternative:

1. Availability issues – Agar agar is not always easily available in local grocery stores.
2. Cost considerations – It may be more expensive than common thickeners.
3. Texture preference – Some people prefer a softer, creamier gel.
4. Recipe modification – You may want to adjust firmness.
5. Allergy or dietary adjustments – Though rare, some prefer other plant-based options.

Before choosing a substitute, always ask:

• Does the recipe require firm slicing?
• Is the gel soft and creamy?
• Is it for baking or no-bake?
• Is it vegan?

The answers determine your best alternative.

Best Substitutes for Agar Agar in Baking

1. Gelatin (Best Non-Vegan Substitute)

4

 

Gelatin is the closest functional substitute for agar agar. It is derived from animal collagen and widely used in desserts.

How It Compares

• Softer and more elastic texture
• Melts at body temperature
• Requires refrigeration to set
• Not vegetarian or vegan

Conversion Ratio

Agar is stronger than gelatin.

1 teaspoon agar powder ≈ 2 to 2.5 teaspoons gelatin powder

Best Used In:

• Cheesecakes
• Mousses
• Puddings
• Custards
• Marshmallows

Important Tip:

Always bloom gelatin in cold water before heating. Never boil it, as high heat reduces its setting ability.

2. Cornstarch (For Thickening, Not Firm Gels)

4

 

Cornstarch works well when agar is being used as a thickener rather than a firm setting agent.

How It Compares

• Thickens but does not create a firm gel
• Produces a glossy finish
• Needs heat activation

Conversion Ratio

Replace 1 teaspoon agar with 1 tablespoon cornstarch mixed in water.

Best Used In:

• Pie fillings
• Sauces
• Custards
• Fruit toppings

Not Suitable For:

• Firm jelly cubes
• Vegan marshmallows
• Sliceable desserts

3. Pectin (Great for Fruit-Based Recipes)

4

 

Pectin is naturally found in fruits and is commonly used in jams and jellies.

How It Compares

• Works best with sugar and acid
• Creates soft, jam-like texture
• Ideal for fruit recipes

Conversion Ratio

Follow package instructions, as pectin strength varies.

Best Used In:

• Fruit jellies
• Jam-based desserts
• Fruit glazes

Not Suitable For:

• Dairy-based recipes
• Cheesecakes

4. Arrowroot Powder (Gentle Thickener)

Arrowroot is a plant-based starch similar to cornstarch but produces a clearer finish.

How It Compares

• Smooth texture
• Not suitable for firm gels
• Sensitive to high heat

Conversion Ratio

Use 2 tablespoons arrowroot for every 1 teaspoon agar.

Best Used In:

• Sauces
• Fruit fillings
• Light custards

5. Tapioca Starch

Tapioca provides chewiness and mild thickening.

Works Well In:

• Puddings
• Pie fillings
• Cream-based desserts

It does not replicate agar’s firm texture but adds body.

6. Xanthan Gum (For Stabilizing)

Xanthan gum thickens liquids and stabilizes mixtures but does not form a firm gel like agar.

Use only small amounts (¼ teaspoon at a time).

Vegan Alternatives to Agar Agar

If you need a plant-based replacement, consider:

• Pectin
• Arrowroot
• Tapioca starch
• Carrageenan (another seaweed extract)

Carrageenan is actually closer to agar in function and can be used in similar applications, especially in dairy-free puddings.

How to Substitute Agar Agar in Different Baking Recipes

1. Vegan Cheesecake

If agar is unavailable:

• Use gelatin (non-vegan)
• Or combine cornstarch + coconut oil (vegan)

For firm slicing, gelatin gives best results.

2. Fruit Jelly

Best substitute: Pectin or gelatin.

If using gelatin:

• Double the quantity compared to agar.
• Chill for at least 4 hours.

3. Panna Cotta

Gelatin is ideal here because panna cotta traditionally has a soft wobble.

4. Custards and Cream Fillings

Cornstarch or arrowroot works better than gelatin if you want a creamy, spoonable texture.

5. Mirror Glaze

Gelatin is commonly used. Agar creates a firmer glaze but sets faster.

Understanding Texture Differences

One of the biggest challenges when replacing agar agar is matching texture.

Choosing the wrong substitute can dramatically change your dessert.

Common Mistakes When Substituting Agar Agar

1. Using equal amounts of gelatin and agar (incorrect ratio)
2. Boiling gelatin
3. Not activating cornstarch with heat
4. Forgetting that agar sets quickly
5. Ignoring sugar requirement when using pectin

Professional Baking Tips

If you are developing recipes for commercial use (such as baking mixes or dessert ingredients):

• Always run small test batches
• Record exact gram measurements
• Consider humidity and temperature
• Label clearly if vegan or non-vegan
• Adjust sugar levels when using pectin

For consistent results in packaged baking ingredients, maintaining standardized gel strength is essential.

When Should You NOT Substitute Agar Agar?

Avoid substitution if:

• The recipe requires room-temperature stability
• You need sharp-cut jelly cubes
• It’s a vegan commercial product
• Texture precision is critical

In these cases, it is better to use agar agar directly.

Final Thoughts

Substituting agar agar in baking recipes is absolutely possible—but it requires understanding texture, structure, and setting behavior.

Here’s a quick summary:

• For closest match (non-vegan): Use gelatin
• For fruit-based recipes: Use pectin
• For thickening only: Use cornstarch or arrowroot
• For vegan options: Use pectin or carrageenan

Each substitute changes the final result slightly, so adjust expectations and test carefully.

With the right approach, you can confidently modify any recipe—even without agar agar in your pantry.